SK is one of those systems that always gets brought up in our guild, and then dismissed as a not fair system, so it is very interesting to hear you say that :D We have one officer/guildie (he alternates) who loves the idea of SK! I was always undecided as I guess I didn't like the idea if people having to get only one item and then there was the whole thing I read about having SK for each role as opposed to each member in the guild and I lost interest.

We used to use a form of DKP, but now being 10 man only, there is not really any need for a loot system, we all just talk about it.

I think my problem with loot systems is I don't really care about the loot, I am one of those people that takes it , if it is going to get sharded, but I don't care if I am the first person with an item or not, as long as we are killing stuff!!

One of the biggest lessons I learnt was not all loot is what it seems either. I now ask from input from ANYONE that wants an item - if they know it is BiS for their class to say so, because as much as I can read up and have mods and go nuts - I am not a theorycrafter nor am I ever going to remember every single class/spec and gear choices :) It is part of their responsility as a raiding member to advise what pieces they are after so it makes loot distribution much easier :)____But I made them mistake once and copped a flogging from all the guildies involved, was a very very horrible night.