olimay
6p4 comments posted · 0 followers · following 0
14 years ago @ Beyond Growth - Fixing Cindy's Compute... · 0 replies · +1 points
I certainly empathize with criticism of psychiatry's overemphasis on certain kinds of treatment. Psychiatric medicine is a mess, more of a mess than the mess that is medicine in general. (Which, as an industry, does a lot of stuff in a quite unscientific manner.) Perhaps your complaint is medicine, and not about any purported philosophy of mind?
I'm trying to fish out the actual sources of disagreement. My concern is you're misunderstanding or misrepresenting a certain set of scientific and philosophical beliefs when your real dispute is elsewhere.
14 years ago @ Beyond Growth - Fixing Cindy's Compute... · 2 replies · +1 points
epiphenomenal? I don't see that position represented anywhere. The
hard materialists should say that mind is complex abstraction of
neural patterns, so thought is as real is neural activity. The
substance dualists think consciousness is quantum gravity (Penrose) or
some undiscovered thing, but their claim on the ontological
distinctness is even stronger than the materialists.
This makes me curious. Can you point me to any random article that you
think espouses or advances the view that consciousness is an
epiphenomenon?
14 years ago @ Beyond Growth - Fixing Cindy's Compute... · 4 replies · +1 points
That's all I wanted to say, since I think your point is that popular advice, and perhaps some psychology puts too much emphasis on the wrong level of organization. That is a very good point.
I *don't* think you're actually trying to posit that the hard problem of consciousness is fundamentally intractable. (If you *are* trying to do so, I'm gonna have to send you over to Eliezer Yudkowsky's Less Wrong Zombies sequence.)
14 years ago @ Catskill Cottage Seed - The Perfect Search · 0 replies · +1 points