well fair comment, i dont care what numbers games sell, so long as they keep producing quality and great games keep coming out,halo will sell regardless simply because of the brand, halo wars sold so well and people were buying this blind, the 3 games shops i visit all staff memeber thought it was hillarious that kids were pre ordering halo wars and going crazy over, only to trade it back in 1 day later because they thought it was an FPS, the shop doesnt care as its a sale for them, but it shows the name sells the game, i dont see any argument, xbox will always outsel ps3 until the install base is the same or larger, even then halo will always sell, same for gears, mass effect, fable etc the 1 year gap MS has was the best thing they could have done

zinc im not putting all my eggs in icons basket, im giving you an example of a consumer who prefers ps3 but owns all consoles, bought halo odst and his view is its an expansion and not worth the money, that doesnt mean he is wrong, its just means you dont agree with his point of view, i agree with him and alot of kids at the game shop trading it in also agree, there is no right and wrong its just personal preference, at least icon bought the game and didnt just disregard it as its an exclussive title not on the system he prefers.

i dont think youll find an american site that isnt bias, why even predict low sales for sony games if you play an xbox, why do you care? no zinc you didnt call any sony fans fools but with your sweeping statements this is exactly what it amounts to,
i give up with this site and its narrow minded fans, its about video games and creativity if you dont like a game ok but its all entertainment, no need to slag off games or systems, if you dont own a system no need to comment, if you dont like a game thats fine, doesnt make it shit just means it not what your into. If someone thinks ODST is an expansion and over priced, just accept that if you love the game great play it love it and enjoy,

oh god NPD that says it all, NPD is just america ! american is the best selling region for xbox yes thats correct,
i love how people just live in their own bubble, like the rest of the world doesnt count.
who cares about sales, i was in my game shop at the weekend and halo odst was being traded in by quite a few kids,bought it finished it, in my view one of these over rated games these days is halo, a game built on a 2 year old engine, there were complaints in the game shop about the price of the game and sorry if you dont like that thats just what i saw.

wow and this is why im starting to loose interest in the warzone and this site, how are you going to predict sales failure for uncharted 2 and ratchet, let me guess are you only going to count sales in the USA since you only care about the country you live in, and USA xbox is king, and wow most ps3 slims that were sold were to existing ps3 users, oh my god your as bad a sony fan boy,
this just makes me loose interest in true gamer sites since they arent true gamers, i love gears of war and i hate halo, i hated warhawk but love uncharted, im sure ill love uncharted 2 as the multiplayer beta was amazing, so games on smash call odst customers fools and youve just done the same to all sony customers, well done.

ok so games on smash can go a little over the top, but how come you never address analog hype guys ? their pod cast always has some negative comments about sony, ps3 is just the best blu ray player on the market ?? please
at least people like icon who prefers the ps3, bought halo odst liked the game but doesnt think its worth $60 as its an expansion pack with no real new online multiplayer, now thats fine personal opinion is fine, and the game is already available used in my local game store,
and most warzone people just laugh at hip hop and call him out when he talks about sony or ps3 games, its cseems that most of the warzone prefer 360s to me. I find it quite condesending when torrence just starts laughing in the background when people try to make a joke about hip hops comments on sony, just listen to the last warzone.