I was a fan of Nintendo's Kid Icarus way back when, but I am not sure if that was ever considered an 'arcade' game. If not, it's a toss up between PaperBoy and Tapper (which used to be sponsored by Budweiser, not A&W, which show how old I am!) =) Happy Thanksgiving everyone!

I agree with Davfer - I would love to see the New XBox Experience as a theme for the site, but since that doesn't count, I think you might be able to do a lot with 'A Kingdom for Keflings.' It may be a bit cheesy, but I think you could be very creative with it - or even make it more 'realistic' in some way. ::Shrug::