kills them right up

Surprise surprise, I loved it (like you and your friend, I love CS) and I just had a conversation with a friend about the "plot too weird" issue -- she agrees with your friend! (I swear our friends are both real people) and I ended up defending the plot, which she called "a weird excuse for her to talk about all these [interesting] things." And I was like, but what else are plots?!?! My mom is reading it now and I'm dying to hear what she thinks. She's not a twin but she is the more conventional of two close-in-age sisters -- more Judith than Cassandra (this will make sense after you read Cassandra) and I am curious to know whether Sisterland resonated. Nicole, read them both for our book club?!

I read it right after SISTERLAND by Curtis Sittenfeld ... creepy twins ftw!!

yayyy thank you