Amy, I'm not sure it's possible to have a good Christian review outlet without judging -- at least, taking into consideration -- a book's "theological message." After all, we can't be referring to Christian fiction without bringing with us a set of assumptions about that word "Christian."

Thanks for the mention, Amy. I learned so much from my commenters yesterday. Regarding Christian fiction review sites: The problems I've had is that they seem more out to "endorse" Christian fiction than actually "review" it. The result is lots of 4-5 star reviews, most without critical bite. 1-3 star reviews are seen as "unloving." It's a difficult divide because, on the one hand, the intention of a Christian review site IS to "endorse" quality Christian fiction. The downside is by not providing sharp public criticism we potentially contribute to an echo chamber and, its byproduct, more poorly written Christian fiction. Amy, thanks for all you're doing! Love your stuff!