teresamerica
68p329 comments posted · 10 followers · following 11
12 years ago @ http://robbingamerica.... - Talking About The Supr... · 0 replies · +1 points
12 years ago @ http://robbingamerica.... - The US Primaries Are A... · 0 replies · +1 points
12 years ago @ http://robbingamerica.... - Obama's Nemesis Endors... · 0 replies · +1 points
12 years ago @ Allied Liberty News - Cartoons from the UK... · 0 replies · +2 points
12 years ago @ http://robbingamerica.... - WOW! Sarah Palin going... · 0 replies · +1 points
12 years ago @ http://robbingamerica.... - WOW! Sarah Palin going... · 2 replies · +1 points
12 years ago @ The Impractical Catholic - Ask Tony: What does \... · 0 replies · +2 points
12 years ago @ Outside the Asylum - The tortured rationali... · 2 replies · 0 points
Point taken about the misunderstanding of infallibility. I tend to rely on my husband for feedback on doctrinal issues and was depending on him to have caught that as a mistake if it was one, but it slipped right past him. However, I still tend to think that there is a lack of prudence in hastily, casually and uncritically tossing away centuries of tradition in favor of a modern sensibility merely on the basis of a lack of an infallible declaration to decide the issue (and it should be noted that the apologies of the Blessed John Paul II and our current pope, without denying them their due submission, are not infallible declarations).
CCC 2297 does not define torture (unless you can make a case that it does so in the original Latin). It condemns (non-infallibly) torture "which" fits the characteristics mentioned without defining torture in general apart from those characteristics and without condemning it (unless you and I have a different understanding of the meaning of the English word "which"). There is also a regrettable vagueness in the condemnation ("moral violence"?) which limits its usefulness.
FYI, as a Catholibertarian I support Rick Santorum also (you know, of course, that you disagree, not just with me, but with your candidate), about waterboarding)...
Sincerely, Teresa from Catholibertarian and Teresamerica
12 years ago @ http://robbingamerica.... - To Iran: Go Ahead Make... · 1 reply · +1 points
12 years ago @ The Humble Libertarian - More on My Newsletter ... · 1 reply · +1 points