CB17GOTFLAGGED
105p1,854 comments posted · 1 followers · following 0
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Lawsuit: Erie High stu... · 1 reply · +23 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Lafayette peace concer... · 0 replies · +2 points
First off, they saved lives. In preparation for the invasion of Japan, estimates were one million Allied casualties expected to take Kyushu. The one million casualties does not include the expected casualties of the Japanese. It would have been in the millions though. Going off previous battles, the IJA had KIA of around 95-99%. This is because they didn't surrender and would fight to the death. Probably would guess that the IJN would be more involved in ground fighting with Japan's navy all but destroyed.
We learned that as the war went on, the Japanese changed their defensive tactics. They went from beach defenses, trying to prevent us from even getting a foothold on shore, to digging in and forcing us to root them out. Iwo Jima is the prime example of this. General Kuribayashi moved his defenses into formidable positions, like Mount Suribachi. He let us land on the island and didn't open fire till we already had thousands of Marines ashore. It was only supposed to take a few days to take Iwo Jima, instead it took over 35 days. Okinawa turned out to be more brutal because we also had to deal with a large civilian population.
As far as civilians go, it's hard to estimate how many would have died, but we can look at Saipan and Okinawa. We saw massive civilians suicides because they were brainwashed by the IJA and thought death was better than the falling into American hands. The people on Saipan were not even Japanese citizens, mostly were Taiwanese and Koreans who were Japanese subjects. Okinawa is made up of Okinawan, who see themselves differently from Japanese. It's hard to imagine what actual citizens of Japan would have done. We do know that they were being trained to fight us. Kids were being taught to run under tanks with anti-tank mines. They were teaching them to fight with bamboo spears. They were all willing to die for the emperor because they thought he was a living god.
The last reason we can argue for the use of the bombs was it prevent the Soviets from doing what they did in Europe to Japan. Instead we got rebuild Japan into one of the strongest countries in the world.
We did the right thing because it ended the war. What was amazing is it took two bombs to end it. Even with that there was a failed military coup to prevent the surrender. Oh and more people died in the bombings of Tokyo than the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Lafayette peace concer... · 0 replies · +2 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Fans cheer on U.S. Wom... · 3 replies · +5 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Discovery of WWII rema... · 0 replies · +11 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Discovery of WWII rema... · 0 replies · +13 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Boulder to make offer ... · 0 replies · +18 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Boulder County dog her... · 0 replies · +12 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - After 40 years in Boul... · 2 replies · 0 points
9 years ago @ Daily Camera.com: - Boulder cattle get a m... · 0 replies · +7 points