Eilish
53p101 comments posted · 10 followers · following 0
12 years ago @ Reason Being - Response to criticisms... · 1 reply · 0 points
12 years ago @ Reason Being - Response to criticisms... · 3 replies · 0 points
In all fairness, I'm not one of your regular readers so any details that may have shed light on this and the OP were anywhere but "on my radar." Perhaps it would've been helpful to at least acknowledge that you have addressed them elsewhere and then link to them.
My critique was based solely on my first impressions and I stand by the impression that you switched gears. You clarify here "This post is .... a brief list of topics I feel the need to be vocal about in light of my disagreement with (largely) Christianity’s very vocal comments on the same topics." This is what I surmised after I finished reading your post, but it was your initial title and statements (and point 1) that led me to believe that you were speaking on rights and not on those topics that feel the need to be vocal about. So really I fail to see how I was inaccurate about this and you've just conceded to my point. Furthermore, in the comment above you said "The entire point of the OP was more or less a list of things that piss me off---and my stating that I have a right to speak on them." Do see how you've contradicted yourself? In the first place you admitted it was about your right to speak out, and it wasn't about what pisses you off, and now the post is about what pisses you off and is not about rights.
I'm all about some civil and logical discourse, but I can't do that when you are being inconsistent and even contradictory.
12 years ago @ Reason Being - Response to criticisms... · 5 replies · 0 points
And for the record, I didn't simply "read what I wanted," and to be honest I'm feeling that I could say the same about you and my comments. I don't believe that theists (or Christians specifically) have the authority to use the government to strong arm obedience. I am as conservative in my beliefs as they come (I'm a Calvinist), but I'm also a libertarian which means that I do not support legislation that is theologically based and intended to curtail sin.
My overall point is that your posting is inconsistent. If you wanted to talk about your disagreements with theism, then a better premise would've been "Why I feel the need to speak out" rather than "Why I have a right to speak out." Those are two entirely different statements with different reasons to support. And especially with a blog entitled "Reason Being" you certainly don't want to be putting forth one premise and then supplying reasons which amount to fallacies based on that premise.
15 years ago @ Weekly World News VIP - GIRL HAS 56 STARS TATT... · 0 replies · +1 points
15 years ago @ Glenn Beck - The 912 P... - Stand Up & Lead - 3/24 · 0 replies · +1 points
http://www.constitutionparty.com/
15 years ago @ Glenn Beck - The 912 P... - America's Wish List · 0 replies · 0 points
15 years ago @ Glenn Beck - The 912 P... - Stand Up & Lead - 3/24 · 0 replies · +1 points
15 years ago @ Glenn Beck - The 912 P... - America's Wish List · 0 replies · +2 points
15 years ago @ Glenn Beck - The 912 P... - 4/9/09 - 4/13/09 · 1 reply · +2 points
15 years ago @ Glenn Beck - The 912 P... - Stand Up & Lead - 3/24 · 0 replies · +1 points