LordTiberivs

LordTiberivs

67p

303 comments posted · 1 followers · following 1

11 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Would gun control redu... · 4 replies · +2 points

Gun laws don't stop criminals from getting guns.....

11 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Will more states legal... · 0 replies · +2 points

See, now here is a comment that I'm just not going to argue with you. I have (nearly) zero experience with marijuana, so in essence, my opinion on the matter is uniformed.
I will however, accept your years of law enforcement experience as a credible source of information and carry on.

11 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Will New York City be ... · 2 replies · +4 points

Nope, you don't actually understand what I am saying, OR you are just choosing to ignore it because you are embarrassed by the "mistake" in your initial statement.

You said: "There isn't enough ice to melt to raise the sea level enough to flood NYC, that is just plain scientific fact! "

That statement is incorrect, regardless of the circumstances of how it would come about, it's wrong.

I'm not talking about practicality, I'm talking about YOUR generalization, and MY rebuttal to your dissemination of incorrect knowledge.

Engineers and scientists have the benefit of working in both the ideal (all the ice melting results in....) and the realistic (how much ice would really melt causing....).

The fact that you don't want to accept my ability to present a purely mathematical solution isn't actually my problem.

In fact my LAST comment before this was to explain that while this situation is wildly improbable the math is still sound.

We don't need a Department of Common Sense, we just need Americans in general to not automatically get angry at someone when they are proven incorrect.

Is there enough ice to melt and cover NYC? Yes.
Did you make a statement saying there wasn't enough ice to do so? Yes.
Were you wrong? Absolutely.
Did you present your opinion as "scientific fact? Yup...

So while in a realistic scenario (which by the way I am NOT disagreeing over) NYC will never be permanently flooded in our lifetime, barring any major terrible circumstance. But to say there ISN'T enough ice to do it, I'm sorry, is wrong.

11 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Will New York City be ... · 4 replies · +4 points

None, but it doesn't change the fact that you didn't actually perform any research or crunch any numbers. Do some math, volume of polar ice in existence on Earth, conversion to volumetric gallons of water, add it to the current volume of the planet, recalculate circumference based on new overall volume..... 65ish meters of sea level rise.

But scientifically speaking, there IS enough ice that could melt and flood NYC.

I'm not a knowledge guru of everything. But I am an accomplished engineer, and I can perform volumetric calculations.

I'm not trying to insult you Papdawg, but what you said was empirically incorrect..... sorry.

11 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Will New York City be ... · 6 replies · +3 points

Actually if ALL the polar ice (2100m thick in many locations) melted, and I mean ALL. Then the sea level would rise somewhere between 190-215 feet. So yes, if all the polar ice melted NYC would be completely underwater.

THAT, is a scientific fact.

12 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Will Casey Anthony be ... · 0 replies · +2 points

Although I don't agree with the verdict. You can't really blame the jury. The prosecution is charged with the task of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The jury cannot convict someone on the evidence of gut reactions.

And if something terrible happens to that girl upon her release..... who cares?

12 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Is OPEC a cartel? · 0 replies · +3 points

I always thought that was what the C stood for....

12 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Will science destroy us? · 0 replies · +2 points

This is ridiculous..... I would like to turn your thoughts to the 700+ year period called the Dark Ages, where the church basically mandated that scientific thought and revolution was heretical.... You want to live like that again? Toothless and middle aged at 26? Ancient at 40? Science is all we have sometimes.

12 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Should all local gover... · 0 replies · +2 points

Careful with that joke, it's an antique....

12 years ago @ DEBATEitOUT.com - Should the DREAM Act b... · 1 reply · +2 points

Uncalled for remark.