I would love to have him as a teacher, too bad I live so far away. He doesnt seem cocky to me, but I guess it I would have to take his class. The fact that he took the time to comment back says to me that hes not as bad as everyone says. Seems like a lot of freshmen comments to me, we get a lot of those at my school as well. In fact one of the best professors I have had didnt get a good review on RMP. Anyway, I'll be buying his book and maybe one day I can meet him :)